Everyone can experience emotional damage, but not all know when or how to voice it in a legal way. The rise of suing for emotional distress has opened doors for many to address their silent sufferings. But when does emotional turmoil warrant an emotional distress lawsuit? Dive into this guide to unravel when and how the law stands by those grappling with unseen scars.

Quick Facts: Suing for Emotional Distress

  • Emotional distress symptoms encompass depression, anxiety, insomnia, and significant weight changes.
  • To win intentional infliction claims, you must prove deliberate behavior causing emotional turmoil.
  • Negligent infliction claims need proof breach of duty leading to profound emotional suffering.
  • In small claims court, you can get up to $10,000, but, severe cases like PTSD might touch $100,000 and more.
  • 11 states (Alaska, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Kansas, Maryland, Mississippi, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, and Tennessee) have caps on non-economic damages ranging from $250,000 to $750,000.

Emotional Distress and Mental Anguish

Emotional distress, a term close to mental anguish meaning, is the mental pain one feels due to someone else’s actions. But, how does the law see this? Let’s take a closer look at the legal nuances of these terms.

suing for emotional distress level of stress

 

What Does Emotional Damage Mean?

A staggering 41% of US adults have grappled with high levels of psychological distress. Yet, not every instance provides reasons to sue for emotional distress in the legal arena.

Emotional distress is the psychological toll one bears due to certain events or actions, leading to feelings like anxiety, shame, or insomnia. It’s not just about hurt feelings; it’s about genuine mental repercussions often ignited by others.

In the courtroom, this distress is tangible harm, giving grounds for a lawsuit.

 

Signs of Emotional Suffering

Recognizing emotional suffering is the first step to realizing the gravity of emotional distress cases won in courts. Common signs include:

  • Severe anxiety or depression
  • Panic attacks
  • Uncontrollable anger or bouts of crying
  • Social withdrawal or isolation
  • Chronic headaches or stomachaches
  • Gain or lose weight
  • Insomnia

Those grappling with such emotional distress examples have a legal avenue, potentially suing for emotional abuse or mental distress.

law read also

Intentional vs Negligent Infliction

When it comes to suing for emotional damages, the law differentiates between intentional and negligent infliction.

suing for emotional distress intentional vs negligent

 

Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress

Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED) is a legal term for when someone’s actions, far more severe than mere rudeness, intentionally wreak emotional havoc on another.

Here’s what you need to know for an IIED claim:

01

Extreme Conduct

The behavior must be outrageous, far beyond what's considered acceptable. It's about actions that cause significant emotional distress.
02

Intent

The person causing the distress must have done so on purpose, either by acting with complete disregard for the potential harm.
03

Causation

There must be a clear link between the behavior and the emotional distress. The distress should be a foreseeable result of the actions.
04

Severe Distress

The emotional pain must be severe, affecting the victim's mental well-being and daily life.

For example, if someone blackmails you for a long time, causing moral harm, this is an IIED case.

Remember, there’s a ticking clock on IIED claims. The intentional infliction of emotional distress statute of limitations is 2 years. Don’t let time run out on seeking justice.

 

Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress

Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress (NIED) is a legal avenue for those who’ve suffered emotional turmoil due to another’s careless actions. It’s not about intentional harm but rather negligence that leads to emotional distress.

Here’s a breakdown of an NIED claim:

01

Duty of Care

The defendant had a responsibility to act in a way that wouldn't harm the plaintiff. This responsibility arises when harm from the defendant's actions is foreseeable.
02

Breach of Duty

The defendant failed in their responsibility, either by acting carelessly or not acting when they should have. For example, if you slip and fall in a store due to the wet floor, which resulted in a fracture and no help.
03

Foreseeability

The defendant's negligence directly led to the plaintiff's emotional distress. This distress was a foreseeable outcome of the defendant's actions.

It’s about holding individuals accountable for the emotional aftermath of their careless actions.

 

Case “Bullying at school”

For example, how to sue a school for emotional distress? If a campus overlooked instances of bullying, leading to emotional turmoil, the student might consider suing the college for emotional distress.

This case aligns with NIED criteria. The school owed the student a duty of care and failed to uphold it, leading to emotional distress. Engaging with classmates, potential witnesses, and the school psychologist can strengthen your position in this matter.

 

Case “Witnessing a relative’s injury”

Another case is when a family stands on the sidewalk, and the DUI or OVI driver veers onto it, resulting in the involuntary manslaughter or mutilation of a family member. A relative who witnesses this tragic event may experience profound emotional trauma. This witness could sue the driver for emotional distress due to the traumatic incident they observed.

 

Case “Loss of social security support”

And finally, can you sue social security for emotional distress as an NIED case? Yes, consider a person dependent on Social Security benefits who stops receiving them due to an administrative error. This abrupt loss of support can cause severe stress and anxiety, especially if they have no other means.

If they can prove their emotional distress resulted from the Social Security Administration’s negligence, they may have a valid NIED case. The administration, responsible for timely benefit distribution, failed in its duty by stopping benefits. The individual’s significant emotional distress was a foreseeable outcome of this negligence.

Proving Emotional Distress in Court

One of the most challenging aspects of an emotional distress lawsuit is the burden of proof. How do you prove emotional distress, especially when the scars are internal? Let’s figure it out.

suing for emotional distress proofs

Here’s how to prove emotional distress in court:

  • Your Testimony: Detail how the defendant's actions led to your emotional pain, its symptoms, and its impact on your life.
  • Expert Opinions: Psychologists or psychiatrists can vouch for the severity of your distress, linking it directly to the defendant's actions.
  • Solid Documentation: Keep records like medical appointments, therapy notes, and medication prescriptions that show you sought help for your distress.
  • Witness Accounts: Those who saw the events unfold can confirm the defendant's behavior and its emotional toll on you.
  • Physical Signs: Document any physical symptoms, like insomnia or weight loss, that stemmed from your emotional distress.
  • Mental Health Diagnosis: A diagnosis, such as depression or PTSD, due to distress can be powerful evidence.
  • Consistency is Key: Ensure your accounts align every time you recount them.
  • Long-Term Impact: Show that your distress wasn't momentary but affected your daily life over an extended period.
  • Legal Precedents: Use past cases that proved emotional distress to strengthen your claim.

Keep in mind, the accused will mount a strong defense. Tread carefully, as false claims of suing for emotional distress could backfire with penalties.

The Emotional Distress Lawsuit Process

Let’s look at whether can you sue someone for emotional distress and unravel the journey from start to finish.

suing for emotional distress lawsuit

 

Initiating a Mental Distress Lawsuit

Here’s a streamlined guide to help you understand the civil lawsuit for emotional distress process:

  • Partner with an emotional distress attorney. Their expertise will determine if your case holds water. Share every detail with your lawyer, from emotional symptoms to medical treatments.
  • Your attorney will gather evidence, from witness accounts to opinions. You may bring in expert witnesses, like psychologists, to confirm your emotional turmoil.
  • The lawyer drafts and files a complaint, initiating the lawsuit.
  • The defendant receives a summons, alerting them of the case. They'll respond, either admitting or denying the allegations.
  • Before hitting the courtroom, both parties might negotiate, aiming for a settlement. If you don't reach an agreement, prepare for a trial.

Remember, suing for pain and suffering emotional distress can be a challenging process, but with the right emotional distress attorney, you can seek the compensation you deserve.

 

legal read

Potential Damages and Compensation

Victims often wonder, how much can I sue for emotional distress? Here’s a concise breakdown of the damages you can seek when you sue for mental anguish:

01

Economic Damages

These are tangible losses with a specific monetary value. They cover actual financial losses due to the incident causing emotional distress. Examples of emotional distress damages in this category include medical expenses for therapy, counseling, and medication, as well as lost wages for time off work.
02

Non-Economic Damages

These are subjective and relate to the emotional and psychological impact of the distressing event. They compensate for the pain, suffering, and emotional trauma experienced. Examples include pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and loss of consortium (companionship, support, and affection from a spouse or partner).
03

Punitive Damages

If the defendant acts with extreme malice, courts might award punitive damages to deter future misconduct.

Some jurisdictions limit the amount of compensation for non-economic damages, including emotional distress. These caps can vary by state and may affect the most amount you can receive. But, you can count on a restraining order for the duration of the pre-trial investigation.

Also, you may be able to recover your attorney’s fees and other legal costs if you win the lawsuit.

 

Navigating the Trial with Emotional Distress Lawyers

While many cases settle out of court, some proceed to trial. Here’s a quick rundown:

  • Jury Selection: The court selects an impartial jury.
  • Opening Statements: Both sides preview their arguments.
  • Evidence Presentation: The court presents witnesses and documents to support claims.
  • Cross-Examination: Attorneys challenge the opposing side's witnesses.
  • Closing Arguments: Each party makes its final case to the jury.
  • Deliberation: Jurors discuss and decide on the verdict.
  • Verdict: The jury announces if the defendant is liable for your emotional distress and the damages owed.

Unhappy with the result? You might be able to appeal, focusing on legal missteps during the trial. Victorious? Your emotional distress lawyer will ensure you get the awarded compensation.

Variations in State Laws and Considerations

Let’s look at the variations in the example of several states.

suing for emotional distress in states

 

Can you sue for emotional distress in Texas?

The question has a clear answer – yes. But, you can’t file a separate suing for emotional distress. Instead, it’s wrapped into personal injury claims as non-economic damages. For a valid emotional distress claim in Texas, you usually need a physical injury that’s medically verifiable. So, emotional distress claims often go hand-in-hand with tangible personal injury cases.

 

Suing for emotional distress in California

California recognizes “bystander” claims, allowing individuals to sue for loss of enjoyment of life if they’ve seen a close family member get harmed due to someone else’s negligence, even without any personal physical injury.

 

Can you sue someone for emotional damage in Florida?

Under Florida law, to state a cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress, a complaint must allege 4 elements:

  • Someone caused you mental suffering.
  • Their behavior was so outrageous it crossed the bounds of decency.
  • Their actions directly led to your emotional distress.
  • The damage you experienced was intense.

Florida law emphasizes the outrageousness of the conduct rather than the victim’s response. The state’s courts often shy away from suing for loss of enjoyment of life claims stemming from workplace issues. So typical co-worker harassment might not meet the “outrageous” benchmark, no matter how blatant.

Also, the statute of limitations on emotional distress in Florida is 4 years, which is twice longer than in other states.

 

Suing for emotional distress in Virginia

In Virginia, seeking damages for emotional distress comes with tighter constraints than in many other states. For emotional distress claims in Virginia, mere symptoms like anxiety, depression, or sleeplessness won’t suffice unless accompanied by a physical injury or evidence of intentional misconduct. The state sets a high bar for these claims, demanding physical harm or proof of deliberate or reckless behavior.

Virginia courts are often skeptical of these claims, wary of potential exaggerations or fabrications. The behavior in question must exceed all bounds of decency, as illustrated by Virginia’s case law.

So, what is the statute of limitations on emotional distress in Virginia? Emotional distress claims fall under the two-year limit set for personal injuries.

 

Suing for emotional distress in New York

In the state of New York, if you face a workplace injury due to the negligence of your employer or coworker, your recourse is limited to suing for emotional distress at work. But, if a third party, outside of your employer or coworker, is responsible, you have the right to take legal action against them.

Can you sue the government for emotional distress? Yes, New York has waived its sovereign immunity, but victims must adhere to specific guidelines. If you face discrimination or are a victim of police misconduct, such as false arrest or excessive force, you must file a “notice of claim” to seek recovery.

New York is one of the few states that apply a “zone of danger” rule. So plaintiffs need to prove a risk of serious injury or death in the incident that harmed their immediate relative.

 

Other states

The time frame to file an emotional distress claim differs across states and doesn’t always align with the usual two-year period. Here are examples of state law differences:

Statute of limitations States
1 year Kentucky, Louisiana, Tennessee
3 years Arkansas, Colorado (for auto accidents), Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Montana, New York, North Carolina, Washington, Wisconsin
4 years Nebraska, Utah, Wyoming
5 years Missouri
6 years Maine, North Dakota

Always double-check with local regulations, but this gives you a snapshot!

Concluding Thoughts

In a landmark emotional distress case, Dr. Michael V. Fitzgibbons won a $5.7 million verdict against his former employer, IHHI. The CEO’s intentionally harmful actions and threats led to Dr. Fitzgibbons’ severe emotional turmoil. While the trial court initially sided with IHHI, the Appellate Court reinstated the jury’s decision, emphasizing that employers can be held liable for employees’ actions within their job scope. This case highlights how skillfully navigating the legal system can bring wrongdoers to account for emotional harm.

Considering suing for emotional distress? It’s not just about the pain but building a solid case. If you aim to sue for emotional damage, team up with a mental anguish attorneys or contact us to navigate the legal intricacies.

Frequently Asked Questions

Have any questions about suing for emotional distress?

Contact Us
How to quantify emotional distress damages?

Your injury receives a grade from 1 to 5. Using this grade, the court multiplies your economic damages to calculate your potential recovery.

How much can you sue for emotional distress in small claims court?

On average, up to $10,000, but some PTSD cases involve up to $100,000.

What is the most you can sue for emotional distress?

There’s no fixed cap, but in some cases, it is possible to recover $500,000 and more.

What are the five signs of emotional suffering?

They include depression, anxiety, isolation, weight problems, and physical symptoms linked to emotional turmoil.

William Green lawyer
William Green
Reviewer
Please, rate the article
  • star empty star full
  • star empty star full
  • star empty star full
  • star empty star full
  • star empty star full
4.75/5
Based on 16 reviews

Read More